The Bachelor franchise is shaking things up, and it’s got everyone talking. When Taylor Frankie Paul was announced as the next Bachelorette, fans were left scratching their heads—and not just because she’s a far cry from the typical 'girl next door' we’re used to seeing. Known for her role in The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives and her presence in the 'MomTok' community, Taylor brings a level of fame and controversy to the show that’s unprecedented. From her documented life as a public figure to her involvement in a swinging scandal, she’s anything but your average Bachelorette. Oh, and did we mention she’s a mom of three from previous relationships? But here’s where it gets controversial: Is this a bold move to revitalize the franchise, or a risky gamble that could alienate its core audience?
During a recent City Cruises Live event, former Bachelor host Chris Harrison, ex-Bachelor Ben Higgins, and Bachelorette alum Wells Adams weighed in on the decision. Wells, ever the optimist, sees this as a much-needed shake-up. 'As someone who still works for Disney, I think it’s going to be a really good season,' he said. 'The show rested on its laurels for too long, and bringing in a big star like Taylor could inject new life into it.' But Ben wasn’t so sure. With a laugh, he quipped, 'I don’t work for Disney, so I have nothing to lose,' before raising a valid point: 'Is The Bachelorette the right platform for someone with her background? How do we ensure this feels authentic and not just a publicity stunt?'
And this is the part most people miss: Ben’s concern isn’t about Taylor’s worthiness of love—it’s about the show’s ability to maintain its integrity. 'It could be a home run, but it could also be a very bad season,' he admitted. Chris Harrison, ever the diplomat, simply said, 'We’ll see.' But Ben pressed further, involving his wife Jessica Clarke, who’s never watched the show but is now intrigued by the potential chaos. 'Is this a move that long-term fans will support?' he asked. 'That’s the big question.'
Wells, however, sees another potential issue: the intentions of the contestants. 'Guys might accuse each other of being there just to be on TV with Taylor, not to find love,' he pointed out. 'That drama? Now that would make for fun TV.'
So, here’s the burning question: Is Taylor Frankie Paul the breath of fresh air The Bachelorette needs, or is this a misstep that could backfire? Let’s be honest—this season is going to be a wild ride either way. But what do you think? Is this a genius move or a recipe for disaster? Sound off in the comments—we want to hear your take!
